Same-sex marriage foe appeals to SCOTUS over anti-discrimination law

DENVER — Four years after the U.S. Supreme Court ruled narrowly in favor of a Colorado baker who refused to make a wedding cake for a gay couple, the justices are preparing to take up a potentially more sweeping and consequential question: whether public accommodation laws that require business owners to offer all customers their goods and services infringe on freedom of speech.

Denver wedding website designer Lorie Smith, who opposes same-sex marriage, is asking the high court to strike down Colorado’s Anti-Discrimination Act, which would require her to serve LGBTQ couples or face fines. She says the law, which has no exemptions, forces her to implicitly express support for something that violates her religious beliefs.

PHOTO: Lorie Smith, owner of 303 Creative LLC, says that Colorado's anti-discrimination law violates her freedom of speech. She says she serves everyone but there are certain messages she just can't create.
Lorie Smith, owner of 303 Creative LLC, says that Colorado’s anti-discrimination law violates her freedom of speech. She says she serves everyone but there are certain messages she just can’t create.
ABC News

“While I’m happy to serve everyone, and I have served everyone, including those who identify as LGBT, there are certain messages I am unable to promote through my business,” Smith told ABC News.

The case, 303 Creative LLC v. Elenis, pits the Free Speech Clause of the First Amendment against legislative efforts to stamp out discrimination against minority groups, particularly the LGBTQ community. Lower federal courts sided with Colorado, saying it has an overriding interest in ensuring equal access to publicly available goods and services.

“If you’re open to the public, you need to accommodate everybody. That’s a core of our civil rights law, and it has deep roots in American law,” said Colorado Attorney General Phillip Weiser.

PHOTO: Colorado Attorney General Philip Weiser says business owners must accommodate all customers, regardless of sexual orientation. Speaking to ABC News, he says the equal access principle has deep roots in American law.
Colorado Attorney General Philip Weiser says business owners must accommodate all customers, regardless of sexual orientation. Speaking to ABC News, he says the equal access principle has deep roots in American law.
ABC News

If the justices were to allow a “free speech exemption” from anti-discrimination protections, Weiser said, the impact could extend far beyond sexual orientation to potentially allow discrimination based on someone’s religion, race or ethnicity.

“If a wedding website designer says I will sell Christian websites that have Biblical verses on it, they can choose to design their websites, design their product as they want,” Weiser said. “What they can’t do is say if you’re a same-sex couple, you can’t have this website.”

PHOTO: The Colorado Anti-Discrimination Act makes it illegal for businesses to discriminate against a customer on account of disability, race, creed, color, sex, sexual orientation, religion, age, national origin or ancestry.
The Colorado Anti-Discrimination Act makes it illegal for businesses to discriminate against a customer on account of disability, race, creed, color, sex, sexual orientation, religion, age, national origin or ancestry.
ABC News

In 2018, the Supreme Court sided with Colorado baker Jack Phillips after he was fined by state officials for declining to make a wedding cake for a same-sex couple; but the 7-2 decision focused only on the Colorado Civil Rights Commission’s conduct in the matter, saying the panel had shown undue hostility to Phillips’ religious views during the investigation.

The court at the time did not address the broader question of denying service to certain customers on First Amendment grounds, which it will now consider this fall. Until Smith’s case is resolved, Phillips said he continues to stay out of the lucrative wedding cake business. Smith has also refrained from marketing wedding website services.

PHOTO: Masterpiece Cakeshop owner Jack Philips has stayed out the wedding cake business since 2012 due to ongoing litigation.
Masterpiece Cakeshop owner Jack Philips has stayed out the wedding cake business since 2012 due to ongoing litigation.
ABC News

“The state doesn’t have a right to tell American citizens what to believe and what to speak and what they cannot speak,” Phillips said in an interview at his Masterpiece Cakeshop. “Lorie Smith’s concern is what the state did to me; it could happen to her, or it could happen to anybody.”

Phillips argues that he and Smith are artists and that each custom-made cake and website are acts of personal expression. “The cake itself is a message,” he said. “If it’s not something I would say, then it’s not something I’ll write on a cake.”

PHOTO: The U.S. Supreme Court sided with Jack Philips, owner of Masterpiece Cakeshop, in a 2018 decision that found the Colorado Civil Rights Commission had acted with anti-religious bias toward him.
The U.S. Supreme Court sided with Jack Philips, owner of Masterpiece Cakeshop, in a 2018 decision that found the Colorado Civil Rights Commission had acted with anti-religious bias toward him.
ABC News

LGBTQ advocates see things differently. Since the Court has recognized marriage as a civil right, regardless of sexual orientation, the nature of the couple seeking wedding services shouldn’t be a basis to discriminate, they say.

“And it’s not just cakes and flowers: Think about haircuts, think about clothing design, think about landscape design. Any kind of custom good or service can be thought of as having creative or artistic qualities,” said Jennifer Pizer, acting Chief Legal Officer of Lambda Legal, an LGBTQ advocacy group.

“This case has the potential to blow an enormous hole in our nation’s civil rights laws, and the stakes really could not be higher for LGBTQ people,” Pizer said.

Research published last year by the Journal of Legal Studies found that religious exemptions under civil rights law “can have a significant and robust, even if inadvertent, impact” on customers, estimating a 61% to 85% chance that same-sex couples will experience discrimination when planning a wedding.

“I think that what’s really important is that if somebody decides that they do need to speak up about unfair treatment that we have laws that protect them,” said Rex Fuller, CEO of The Center on Colfax, an LGBTQ community center in downtown Denver.

PHOTO: Colorado has long been at the center of debate over LGBTQ rights. A U.S. Supreme Court decision in Romer vs. Evans, 26 years ago, struck down a Colorado amendment prohibiting protections for LGBTQ people.
Colorado has long been at the center of debate over LGBTQ rights. A U.S. Supreme Court decision in Romer vs. Evans, 26 years ago, struck down a Colorado amendment prohibiting protections for LGBTQ people.
ABC News

Twenty-six years ago, in the Supreme Court case Romer v. Evans, a 6-3 majority struck down a Colorado amendment that prohibited protections for LGBTQ people. The years since have seen significant expansion of rights and equality, but some fear the Smith case could mark a turn.

“There’s anxiety. We’re watching situations in other states, a lot of sort of more conservative states, like actively legislating against transgender folks and transgender acceptance,” said Sable Schultz, The Center’s manager of transgender programs.

Transgender discrimination is at the heart of Phillips’ latest legal battle involving Colorado’s Anti-Discrimination Act. Autumn Scardina, a transgender Denver woman, is currently suing the baker in state civil court for allegedly refusing to design her a pink and blue cake because of her gender identity.

PHOTO: Autumn Scardina, a transgender plaintiff currently suing Jacks Philips for refusing to make her a pink and blue cake, says even though she expected to be turned away the experience still "stung."
Autumn Scardina, a transgender plaintiff currently suing Jacks Philips for refusing to make her a pink and blue cake, says even though she expected to be turned away the experience still “stung.”
ABC News

“As soon as I told him who I was, then it became, I won’t sell it to you,” Scaridna told ABC News. “What I asked for was a pink and blue cake, and he freely admits he makes pink and blue cakes. Even though I was guarded, even though I expected that result and was hoping for the other, it still stung, stung tremendously.”

Phillips maintains he is unable to design a cake celebrating a gender transition because of his religious beliefs. “We told this person, you know, we serve everybody; will gladly serve you – will make other custom cakes for you. You’re welcome to come in and shop, buy cookies, brownies, anything that I have, but I can’t create that cake because it is a message that I couldn’t create.”

The state civil case, which is still pending on appeal, highlights the stakes in the higher-profile showdown playing out in Lorie Smith’s case at the nation’s highest court.

PHOTO: People walk outside the State Capitol on Aug. 30, 2022, in Denver.
People walk outside the State Capitol on Aug. 30, 2022, in Denver.
David Zalubowski/AP

“I’m hoping the U.S. Supreme Court justices will stand for free speech because no one should live in fear of government punishment simply because the government doesn’t agree with their views on a certain topic,” Smith said.

Attorney General Weiser says he’s optimistic the justices will hold the line. “The regulation of conduct to prohibit discrimination is protected activity, and it is really critical that we not break from that,” he said.

Source: ABC News

A tech blog author and superhero who writes about technology and its impact on society, business, and everyday life

Related Posts

Subject of ‘Serial’ podcast could have murder conviction vacated, walk free

Adnan Syed, who was the subject of 2014’s wildly popular podcast “Serial,” is set to appear in a Baltimore courtroom on Monday after prosecutors requested that his 2000 murder conviction…

Read more

Biden comments on American hostage in Afghanistan released in prisoner swap

Mark Frerichs — the last-known American hostage being held by the Taliban — has been released in a prisoner exchange, President Joe Biden confirmed in a statement on Monday. “His…

Read more

Biden closes door on COVID, opens one on 2024: The Note

The TAKE with Rick Klein On at least one very big point, President Joe Biden was definitive. “The pandemic is over,” he said on “60 Minutes” in an interview that…

Read more

Tom Barrack case: Jury selection to begin in trial of former Trump fundraiser

Jury selection begins Monday in the trial of Tom Barrack, the billionaire fundraiser for former President Donald Trump who is charged with illegally lobbying for the United Arab Emirates while…

Read more

President Joe Biden, first lady Jill Biden pay their respects to Queen Elizabeth ahead of funeral

President Joe Biden and first lady Jill Biden on Sunday paid their respects to Queen Elizabeth II as world leaders gathered in London ahead of the late monarch’s state funeral….

Read more

‘This Week’ Transcript 9-18-22: Mayor Eric Adams, Mayor Oscar Leeser and Amb. Oksana Markarova

A rush transcript of “This Week with George Stephanopoulos” airing on Sunday, September 18, 2022 on ABC News is below. This copy may not be in its final form, may…

Read more

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.